Nyaargh! This is another rant on the case of WB/JKR vs. SVA/RDR. If you're sick of them, I'm sorry. I just wanted to put my opinion forward, as I haven't seen anyone actually supporting Steve, yet.
M'kay, here's the deal. Yes, Steve is morally wrong to be wanting to make money off JKR's creation. I get that, don't worry. But GODDAMN, people, give the guy a break!
He, too, was against the idea at first, for exactly the same reasons that most are against it now. Quoted from
here:
"Vander Ark said he initially was against the idea, partly because he believed it would violate copyright law. Even after Rapoport assured him they could publish legally, he remained unsure and insisted on a contract clause in which RDR agreed to take on costs caused by any copyright lawsuit."
In my opinion, the fandom's bitching should be solely directed towards Roger Rapoport.
He's the guy who majorly fucked up, here. All the hate towards Steve, it really pisses me off. I bet at least eighty percent of people who are now swearing that they hate Steve and that they think he's a pathetic loser have used the Lexicon, at least once. Personally, I still swear by it.
Steve has played a very major part in making the fandom what it is today. The Lexicon was his creation; he's spent years dedicating his life to the Harry Potter books and community. His site was a part of the Floo Network (which has now broken up, thanks to this ordeal), and has been interviewed on countless HP-related topics. He was more of a core of the fandom than pretty much anyone in the fanfiction or fanart community, I think.
And seriously, you guys who're calling him pathetic for crying, put yourself in his position! He idolises this woman, far more than most in the fandom do, and for Jo to come out and bluntly say that she thinks him a fool, and that she only awarded the fansite award because it was the nice thing to do (as quoted by Leaky,
here), and that she deeply regrets it, hell, I would've been sobbing a LONG time ago. Do you realise how much Steve's self-confidence will have been lowered now? His hero, the woman he's dedicated the last ten years of his life to thinks him an idiot? Jeez.
On the same tone, you guys who're now mocking him for what he
looks like? That's low. That's really low. I honestly am disappointed in the fandom, here. I completely expected better. Knocking him for making a bad decision and thinking it to be on some level right to make money from JKR's creation, fine. But laughing at him for crying and saying that the man is ugly? That's just not on, guys.
Before reading all the crap that people have been writing about SVA, I was actually neutral. But now, I'm more inclined to side with Steve. I don't care what your opinion of him is, he doesn't deserve the abuse that's flying around the Internet.
If he (or RDR, seeing as they're the ignorant bastards in all of this) would agree to give the money to a charity, then I
would be backing Steve. Sorry, Jo.